Which show is better ?

ScklKid · 07-03-2009, 06:04 PM

1) SMACKDOWN
2)RAW
3) ECW .... WHATS YOURS ...!

RobyD · 07-03-2009, 06:24 PM

I'm pretty sure that the overall decision from everyone on this forum is that Smackdown! is the better show. It is a great mix of both wrestling ability and star power. SD! is easily in the best shape its been in, in years.

ECW, for me, follows it up. It is, wrestling wise, the best one hour of wrestling television today. Where else do you get to see new stars elevated and pushed without straying from what brought them to the dance in the first place?

Raw is horrible. The ending is always lackluster, the feuds are boring, dull and overdone, and there are so many antics on the show that it seems like wrestling is a non matter anymore.

The Raw King · 07-03-2009, 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob

I'm pretty sure that the overall decision from everyone on this forum is that Smackdown! is the better show. It is a great mix of both wrestling ability and star power. SD! is easily in the best shape its been in, in years.

ECW, for me, follows it up. It is, wrestling wise, the best one hour of wrestling television today. Where else do you get to see new stars elevated and pushed without straying from what brought them to the dance in the first place?

Raw is horrible. The ending is always lackluster, the feuds are boring, dull and overdone, and there are so many antics on the show that it seems like wrestling is a non matter anymore.

I will agree with you there. For a long time ECW has been showing some great promis for become a C+ show instead of just a C show. I think although Smackdown is at the best its been since 2002, it will come down as Raw just sucks.

CGS · 07-03-2009, 06:29 PM

Wouldn't say the overall decision would be Smackdown but i'm 100% sure it will be split between SD & ECW. I would be surprised if anyone on her actually chose Raw since pretty much no one on her has anything highly positive to saw about the show. Don't blame them either Raw is terrible atm.

For me anyway it has to be SD. Great stars, great booking, great wrestling, good storylines, SD has it all. Heard some great things about ECW as well but haven't really watched it so i can't really comment on it.

RaiZ-R · 07-04-2009, 12:03 AM

Up until the little mini-draft/trade dealio this week I was ECW, through and through, for months. But now I'm not sure how they'll recover from losing some much talent in one go. I have to say though, Tuesday was a very, very good (re)start.

Smackdown looks set to be the number one show now. It's roster and booking are (in my opinion) the best it's ever had, and with ECW's future in the air, and Raw being so completely and utterly dross, it's not got much competition.

Raw is the lowest of the low in my opinion. Not only below all the WWE's shows (including Superstars, which I download) but also TNA and ROH's weekly's as well. This past few weeks have been interesting, but not a single second of it has shown Raw preparing new stars for the future. It's all been quick fix, ratings-grabbing scams in order to make it look like it's doing better creatively than it actually is. Meanwhile Smackdown is developing new main eventers and solid midcarders in Punk, JoMo, and Ziggler and ECW is priming Christian for main event glory, and filling it's current gaps (where Raw grabbed all it's talent from) with brand new, exciting propostions for us to enjoy.

Necro · 07-04-2009, 12:10 AM

Yeah Smackdown is number one for me, followed by ECW. Raw I watch every week, but honestly it's more for that fact it's on Monday more than anything. I actually started hardcore watching wrestling again, and have enjoyed Superstars a ton. Straight matches cuts through the bullshit, and gives us what we want. Same with Smackdown as well.

ECW is building stars, and really is something I'm loving lately. I love how they can rebuild, and feature new guys without worrying about ratings. They still bring in the best rating on Sci-fi network, and I'm hoping they eventually get a second hour. Because they could honestly put on a really solid 2 hour IMO.

ScklKid · 07-04-2009, 07:24 AM

Smackdown number 1 for me aswell becuase it has good talent on the show it not bouring and it has my fravouite Divas Layla Melina and maria lol

, Raw is Good beucase i like the storyline between Randy Orton vs Triple H lol but in my opinion it geting bouring now lol , it didn't
ECW is cool

WHY NOT WE RATE THE SHOWS OUT OF TEN

SMACKDOWN = 10/10
RAW = 8.5 / 10
ECW = 8.3/10 lol

but my opinion going to change soon lol

whats your

TrueBlue · 07-08-2009, 12:58 AM

SD! is easily leading the way.

and 2nd is now a bit difficult after they decided to take The Hart Dynasty, Bourne, Swagger, Mark Henry, Finlay away from the show and put Regal and the bella twins there....But they do still have Christian and that's enough to be better than RAW (which has nothing)

Sir Satan · 07-08-2009, 01:37 AM

Well I am only saying Raw because the fact that it's the only show I take time to watch. I stopped watching SD when they moved from Thursday to Friday nights. Raw has been boring the hell out of me, so maybe I should start watching SD again though its very awkward when I'm watching it. I trust all of you guy's opinions so I'm gonna try watching SD this Friday to see how I feel.

Red Devils · 07-08-2009, 09:13 AM

Well I believe all the shows bring something different to the WWE. Raw is the ultimate show of course as it's the main brand with most of the top stars and storylines. Smackdown! is the wrestling brand that creates innovative storylines and action. ECW is the show where they put all the jobbers or guys or who aren't getting much tv time and for the bright up and comers to make there impact. Of course I choose Raw because of it's history.

Which show is better ?

This is a discussion on Which show is better ? within the WWE Discussion forums, part of the Wrestling Forums category; 1) SMACKDOWN 2)RAW 3) ECW .... WHATS YOURS ...!...