Every month I will be going back in time and looking at that month in a previous year across the wrestling world. April's year is going back to 2007.
Quite a lot to cover here - 2 WWE PPVs, all of the major indy promotions ran shows, and a fair bit of puro. There are a few matches that from memory stand out as MOTYCs for the year, so I am looking forward to revisiting as much as I can.
PWG All Star Weekend V: Night 1 (7/4)
Rocky Romero vs Roderick Strong
This was quite good, especially the first half, but also suffered from classic PWG-ism. They started pretty hot and brought it, and both guys are stiff enough that the strike exchanges were pretty enjoyable. My opinion of Roddy through the 2000s was that he was a guy with a good physical skillset but not great at laying out a match, but he did a lot to make me eat my words here. His control section on Rocky was full of nasty spots and kept things moving – backbreaker on the apron, gorilla press into the barricades, a bow and arrow around the ring-post, even tying him in knots around the ropes to set up a running boot. Rocky kept trying to come back and there was a good amount of struggle and stiffness here, and they did a good job with the flash submission teases. It’s just a shame they went 20 minutes rather than 10, the longer this went the more they lost the momentum. This was the second match on a Supercard, no need for this guys to go as long as they did. The best match on this show but even then it should have gone shorter.
Human Tornado vs Claudio Castagnoli
Man, there’s not way Tornado would get away with his abusive boyfriend gimmick these days, even if it was a super heel schtick. This opens with him berating Candice LeRae before flooring her with a slap and threatening to beat the shit out of her if she screws up another match for him. Straight off the bat, Claudio chases Tornado around the ring until Tornado grabs Candice as a human shield, then throws her face first into the ring post. Jeez. I know Candice is a professional and was a consenting adult and athlete in all of this, so personally have no issue with it, but Disco Inferno bursting out in laughter on commentary was really awful. This routine is meant to get over Tornado as a piece of shit, not make you laugh. Claudio gets to beat up Tornado with some big uppercuts and the giant swing early, but it’s all a bit happy-go-lucky rather than something heated. He does hit a great looking head-scissors off the top which would have been impressive even for a guy half his size. Tornado’s heat stuff is all pretty low rent, cheap shots, rest holds and using Candice as a weapon or distraction. I was a fan of the Tornado/Hero/Candice program on the whole but this was a bit of a dud.
Kikutaro vs Matt Classic (Colt Cabana)
Matt Classic was Cabana’s short-lived masked wrestler gimmick he used in Wrestling Society X. This was two great comedy workers doing a full on shlock-fest. Kikuato won’t be for everyone, a lot of his routine with him going at the referee definitely breaks the ‘rules’ of wrestling, but I thought he was quite funny. Cabana really nails the old school heel, Mr Wrestling send-up with his gimmick. I thought all his posing with his “barrel” chest, duck-walking and old school offence like the palm thrusts, iron claw and bearhug were all pretty great. I really enjoyed this, it gave you me what I want from these two guys and was a good palette cleanser after the Tornado stuff.
Kevin Steen vs Jack Evans
This had too much Kevin Steen: Stand Up comedian for my taste, especially straight after an actual comedy match. Nice contrast of style here between Evans’s flying and Steen’s bombs and stiffness, though it never came together as anything interesting or clever. Steen’s chops, powerbombs and fatboy sentons I dig, his tedious crowd-pandering bullshit I don’t. Really makes it feel like he’s out there for yucks rather than a serious match. Evan’s basic offence like kicks and elbows look kinda crummy, but his crazy flippy, twisty spots and flying is all still quite spectacular to watch even 15 years later. I guess there is a point where it is subject to diminishing returns as a springboard 630 should get a bigger reaction than it does, but that’s a minor take. Steen kills Evans dead with a nasty Steenalizer for the decisive finish leading into a title match on Night 2. Match was solid if forgettable.
Kaz Hayashi vs Alex Shelley
Vanilla indy workrate ‘dream match’. They start with the same choreographed chain wrestling sequence you see in a hundred other Alex Shelley matches and it doesn’t get any more interesting or surprising from there. Bland, directionless predictable wrestling. Matches like this are a trope I don’t miss from the 2000s indy scene.
Low Ki vs Davey Richards
This was when Richards was mediocre, but before he was awful. I remember digging a match these two had in one of the TPIs, but they had no chemistry together here and it was much more of a Richards match than a Ki match. Very lacking in direction and almost everything felt like filler. They hit hard enough the few fleeting strike exchanges were decent, but a solid 90% of this was boring and tediously long. Seeing Ki spend most of the match selling for Davey Richards is like watching Mike Tyson getting out-boxed by Logan Paul, no wants to see it and they won’t buy it if they do.
El Generico vs PAC
This was a rematch from the bout these 2 had on the previous ASW, which was the match that really put PAC on the map. I’m a low voter on that match, but will at least cede some of the spots were bonkers. This time round they go much longer and what they do isn’t nearly as spectacular or memorable. The entire match felt like filler until the final few big spots at the end. They didn’t go as crazy or overboard as the first match, but instead it’s mostly just really boring. The difference between Jack Evans and PAC is really clear- Evans feels like a guy with a clearly defined persona and style which contrasts with his opponents, PAC is a super bland guy without much to offer outside big highspots. I can see the appeal of their first match, but this was forgettable.
EDIT - I will update this opening post with my recommend viewing for the month as we go.
RECOMMENDED VIEWING:
- Morishima/Yone vs Akiyama/Rikio
- Strong vs Romero
- Cabana/Talwar vs Kikutaro/Disco
- Ki vs Joe
- Tanahashi vs Nagata
- Cena vs Michaels, RAW