SI Top QB's for 2007

Slimdust

P. Manning Ind.
2. T. Brady NE
3. D. Brees NO
4. C. Palmer Cin.
5. M. Bulger St.
6. M. Hasselbeck Sea.
7. V. Young* Tenn
8. P. Rivers* SD
9. J. Kitna * Det.
10. J. Cutler* Den.
11. T. Romo* Dall.
12. D. McNabb Phil.
13. S. McNair Bal.
14. B. Favre GB
15. C. Pennington Jets
16. J. Delhomme Car.
17. B. Roethlisberger Pit.
18. M. Leinart* Ariz.
19. M. Schaub* Hou.
20. J.P. Losman* Buf.
21. M. Vick Atl.
22. J. Garcia* TB
23. E. Manning Giants
24. T. Green Miami
25. A. Smith SF
26. J. Campbell *Wash
27. R. Grossman*
28. B. Leftwich Jax
29. J. McCown* Oak.
30. T. Jackson*
31. C. Frye Cle.
32. B. Croyle*


Agree?

PS3 Online Name: xJimmyx23

www.haulingkings.com

Twist of Lemon

No Quinn.....? and I suppose I'm inclined to agree, though I think Garcia will do 2 or 3 spots better in Tampa then what they have him at.

Simon

Founder/Admin

Looks about Right. I am partial to Brady in the top slot, but I don't feel like starting a big homer arguement. haha. I would also move Vick way down. He sucks.

Blitzkrieg

Administrator

Alex Smith at 25 behind guys who've never really started in the league? That's bullshit. He started to put some things together last year, it's not too far fetched that he'll improve again this year. fuck.

Freak

What do the asterisks represent?

For me, the biggest injustice is Jeff Garcia. After the season he had last year, I'd move him up about ten spots on that list. Also, Vince Young is way, way too high.

Slimdust

I'm sorry i should of posted this before. The Asterisks mean ''Has not spent the last two seasons as starter''.

And also they rated only the qb's that will start the season. That is why Brady Quinn and J Russel are not listed.

PS3 Online Name: xJimmyx23

www.haulingkings.com

Griff0rd

TNA Moderator

I think Jay Cutler , Alex Smith , and McNabb (if he stays healthy) will all outperform their rankings... I don't expect Young to do that well...

Freak

Alex Smith definitely showed promise last year, but he's still the kind of guy who has a huge monkey to get off his back. If he improves again this year, I think you'll see him a lot higher on these lists next year -- but for now, I don't blame people for having low expectations again.

As for the rest of the list, it's bothering me more and more (which I'm sure is what Peter King was going for).

Blitzkrieg

Administrator

Freak, don't forget that Smith will also have more reliable weapons this season..

Personally, I can't wait for the season to start. I really think the niners have a great chance at competing for that division title..

Freak

I'm a huge Niners advocate going into the season, don't get me wrong. Frank Gore is easily my favourite running back in the league (until Brandon Jackson takes over, that is), and Darrell Jackson is EXACTLY what the doctor ordered for that offense (like, so exactly I can't even think of a stronger word than exactly!).

BUT, Alex Smith is still a guy under immense pressure, and also a guy remembered by some as having played like absolute dogshit in his rookie year. I do believe he'll outperform that low ranking, but some people just need to see a bit more from him, that's all.

(That said, what has anybody fucking seen about Matt Schaub, besides preseason?)