Best of the Best

Slimdust

In the positions below, list first the best in your opinion of all time, and the best playing today...

NFL
QB:

RB:

TE:

WR:

OL:

DL:

LB:

CB:

S:

MLB:
1st:

2nd:

3rd:

SS:

CF:

LF:

RF:

Catcher:

Pitcher:

PS3 Online Name: xJimmyx23

www.haulingkings.com

Griff0rd

TNA Moderator

All -Time

NFL
QB: John Elway

RB: Walter Payton

TE: Shannon Sharpe

WR: Jerry Rice

OL: Washington Redskins (John Ruggins ERA)

DL: Chicago Bears (Ditka Era)

LB: Derrick Thomas

CB: Rod Woodson

S: Steve Atwater



Current

QB: Peyton manning

RB: LaDanian Tomlinson

TE: Tony Gonzales

WR: Steve Smith

OL: Denver Broncos

DL: Chicago Bears

LB: Brian Urlacher

CB: Champ Bailey

S: John Lynch

Twist of Lemon

While im new to this whole "NFL" thing <_<

QB: Brady Quinn

Slimdust

I'll do baseball now and ill do football later.. Keep in mind i didnt look up any stats so best all time for me and best now is prolly more on the line just who i like =)

MLB:
1st: Best all time: Lou Gehrig Best Right Now: Mark Tex

2nd: All Time: Jackie Robinson Right Now: I really like Ian Kinsler but give him two more years, so ill say Craig Biggio even though he isnt as good now.


3rd: All time: Cal Ripken jr. Best Right now: A-Rod

SS: Cal Ripken Jr. Best Right Now: Derek Jeter is over Rated, Mike Young

CF: All Time: Ken Griffey Jr. Best Right now:Torri Hunter

LF: All Time: Ted Williams Right now: Manny Ramirez

RF:All Time: Hank Aaron Right now: Garry Sheffield

Catcher: All Time: Ivan Rodriguez Best Right Now: Ivan Rodriguez

Pitcher: All Time: Nolan Ryan... Right Now: Tie with Josh Becket and Santana

PS3 Online Name: xJimmyx23

www.haulingkings.com

Inogenius

Politics Moderator

You make me horny with that pick.

NFL
QB: Dan Marino

RB: Jim Brown

TE: Kellen Winslow Sr.

WR: Jerry Rice

MLB:
1st: Roy Sievers

2nd: Ryne Sandberg

3rd: Cal Ripken Jr.

SS: Omar Vizquel

CF: Mickey Mantle

LF: Albert Belle

RF: Rocky Colavito

Catcher: Thurman Munson

Pitcher: Greg Maddux

Freak

Worst list ever.

Freak

I didn't put a whole lot of thought into my picks, so feel free to disagree.

NFL

QB (all-time): Peyton Manning (after the SB, we can stop kidding ourselves)
QB (right now): Peyton Manning

RB (all-time): Jim Brown
RB (right now): LaDainian Tomlinson

TE (all-time): Kellen Winslow
TE (right now): Antonio Gates

WR (all-time): Jerry Rice
WR (right now): Steve Smith

OL (all-time): Bruce Matthews
OL (right now): Walter Jones

DL (all-time): Reggie White
DL (right now): Richard Seymour

LB (all-time): Lawrence Taylor
LB (right now): Brian Urlacher

CB (all-time): Deion Sanders
CB (right now): Champ Bailey

S (all-time): Ronnie Lott
S (right now): Ed Reed

Simon

Founder/Admin

All Time in Red, Current in Black

This is also off the top of my head, so forgive me if someone slips through my rattled brain.

NFL
QB: Man, too many good ones to choose from.........Joe Montana...
Peyton Manning

RB: Barry Sanders (just because he was so good on such horrible ass teams)
LaDainian Tomlinson

TE: No idea..........
Dallas Clark

WR: Jerry Rice
Chad Johnson (only because Marvin is starting to decline)

OL: no idea. I dont follow the entire NFL's rosters to give a fair pick

DL: Reggie White
Richard Seymour. (thank you for agreeing there Freak)

LB: Lawrence Taylor
Brain Urlacher

CB: Deion Sanders (baaaaaaaaaaahahahahahah, I keed) Ty Law
Champ Bailey

S: Ronnie Lott
Ed Reed or Rodney Harrison when healthy, but he never is so Reed

Baseball is so much more up my alley

MLB:

1st: Albert Pujols
Albert Pujols

2nd: Ryan Sandberg
Chase Utley

3rd: Mike Schmit (spelt wrong?)
Miguel Cabrera (and still only 23!!)


SS: Alex Rodriguez
Jose Reyes

(there are alot of old time great OF's that I am not sure of their position so forgive me if I am wrong)

CF: Ken Griffey Jr.
Torii Hunter

LF: Hank Aaron
Manny Ramirez

RF: Mickey Mantle (although my gut is telling me he was CF, But he needs to be on this list somehow)
Jeff Francouer (not a ton of good RF's currently in baseball)

Catcher: Johnny Bench
Russell Martin

Pitcher: Roger Clemens
Jake Peavy


I love baseball

Simon

Founder/Admin

I would also like to point out that Nolan Ryan had longevity, but was by NO MEANS one of the best pitchers ever.

Take away his strikeouts (by that I mean now give him some ground ball outs or pop ups instead of K's) and his stats look pretty average at best.

He stayed on about 8 years too long too.

WackoJako

All-time picks in bold

NFL
QB: John Elway

Peyton Manning

RB: Jim Brown

LT

TE: I unno

Antonio Gates

WR: Jerry Rice

Torry Holt

OL: Tom Nalen

Steve Hutchinson

DL: Reggie White

Dwight Freeney

LB: Lawrence Taylor

Brian Urlacher

CB: Ty Law

Champ Bailey

S: rod Woodson

Ed Reed

MLB:
1st:

Albert Pujols

2nd: Ryne Sandberg

Chase utley

3rd: A-rod

A-rod

SS: Cal Ripken Jr.

Jose' Reyes

CF: Willie Mays


Andruw Jones

LF: Barry Bonds

Vlad Guerrero

RF: Babe Ruth

Ichiro

Catcher: Mike Piazza

Joe Maurer

Pitcher: Bob gibson

Johan Santana