Should I do this trade?

Danny Diamond

Founder/Admin

The Joneses
·Lloyd, Brandon WR SF
·Moore, Mewelde RB MIN
·Smith, Onterrio RB MIN
·Williams, Roy WR DET

for


Shasta McNasty
·Fitzgerald, Larry WR ARI
·McAllister, Deuce RB NO



I have Fitz and Deuce. I also need WR help.

Blitzkrieg

Administrator

You have to do that trade. Whether the Vikings play Moore or Smith they put up numbers in that vikings offense, both running and catching the ball out of the backfield.

Lloyd is the number one on the niners now. Rattay has averaged well over 300 yards passing during the last few games and Lloyd will continue to be the go to guy.

Roy Williams, I believe is a little nicked up, but he should be fine and with Rogers out for the year, he is the favorite target of Joey Harrington, who is much improved, and should be able to get him the ball on a consistant basis.

Do the trade.

Randy Orton

WC's Resident Alchoholic

I concur.

Freak

I'm the world's biggest Moore supporter, I've made that very clear, but you gotta remember Michael Bennett here too. He's playing this weekend, and he will in all likelihood reclaim his starting gig the moment he returns to full strength (yeah I know, IF is more appropriate).

Also, Lloyd is the 49ers best WR, but I would hardly call him the go-to guy up to this point. He's battled injuries, and even when playing he's only had one good week where he caught like 6 passes. Meanwhile, Eric Johnson is leading the league in receptions, is he not?

I dunno Simon, Deuce McAllister is a lot to give up. Roy Williams is also struggling with an injury right now, and with Boldin coming back, Fitzgerald is gonna have a lot of new room to work with.