I need Fantasy Football advice....and fast

Danny Diamond

Founder/Admin

Should I pull off this deal? I am weary that it would leave my recievers as a bunch of shitbums, and I also feel like I am giving up too much.

Please advise.


My lineup before the trade (we use a flex player, basically you can play one extra player than the normal lineups)

QB: Vick
QB: Kitna
RB: Tiki
RB: Willie Parker
WR: Harrison
WR: Branch (holdout)
WR: Galloway
TE: Shockey

I like my lineup when I see it on paper, but I really have little to no expectations about Vick and Kitna. QB's and RB's dominate our leagues scoring as well.


Players you get:

Player Compare 3 Year Averages NFL Tracking Stats
Player	Salary	Contract	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaTD	PaInt	Rate	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReTD	FL	FPTS
Brady, Tom QB NE	67	0	511	313	3807	26	13	90.5	37	60	1.6	1	0	0	0.0	0	4	275.0
Moulds, Eric WR HOU	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	2	6	3.0	0	78	880	11.3	3	0	107.0
Clayton, Michael WR TB	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	3	16	5.3	0	56	782	14.0	4	0	97.0
Burleson, Nate WR SEA	11	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	3	14	4.7	0	42	596	14.2	4	0	81.0
Stevens, Jerramy TE SEA	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0.0	0	27	325	12.0	3	0	59.0

Players you give up:

Player Compare 3 Year Averages NFL Tracking Stats
Player	Salary	Contract	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaTD	PaInt	Rate	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReTD	FL	FPTS
Harrison, Marvin WR IND	59	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0	1	0.0	0	87	1177	13.5	12	1	250.0
Vick, Michael QB ATL	18	0	269	148	1770	11	9	75.0	87	589	6.8	3	0	-5	0.0	0	4	175.0
Shockey, Jeremy TE NYG	13	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0.0	0	58	697	12.0	5	0	103.0
Schaub, Matt QB ATL	1	0	67	33	412	2	2	66.3	8	51	6.4	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	21.0

Dr. Giganto

no way. very bad deal for you.

I dont know your scoring system, but Vick makes up for a lot of his passing stats (or lack thereof) with running yards/TDs. According to the scoring system I use (which is pretty standard), Vick was the 9th highest scoring QB last year. Brady scored 2.4 fantasy points per game more than Vick.

Jeremy shockey is far superior to Stevens. Shockey was the 2nd highest scoring TE, and scored 4.9 more fantasy points per week than Stevens.

Michael Clayton didnt do squat last year, Eric Moulds is going to a mediocre offense (and he's getting old), and I have little faith in Nate Burleson. Marvin Harrison is still an elite WR, and had the 7th highest fantasy points per game in my league last year.

Dont do the deal. Your team is VERY good, and doesnt need tinkering.

Dr. Giganto

oh, and how many teams are in your league? your team looks pretty stacked.

Danny Diamond

Founder/Admin

12 teams. Thanks for the advice. I am not going to do the deal.

Here is the rest of my lineup. And yes, points almost double if a QB rushes one in or if a RB recieves one in. That type of thing.



Team Name : Jack Bauer

Player	Next	Bye	Avg	Guru	Salary	Contract	Own %	Start %	Status
Active Quarterback	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaInt	PaTD	RuTD	Status
Active Quarterback	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaInt	PaTD	RuTD	Status
Kitna, Jon QB DET	SEA	8	0.0	n/a	6		7	1	409	244	3122	10	17	0	218	134	1442	7	10	0	ActiveReserve
Vick, Michael QB ATL	@CAR	5	0.0	n/a	18		97	52	390	224	2704	14	16	3	269	148	1770	9	11	3	ActiveReserve
Active Running Back	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReTD	Status
Active Running Back	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReTD	Status
Barber, Tiki RB NYG	IND	4	0.0	n/a	52	1	99	98	321	1378	4.3	8	50	2	319	1531	4.8	8	58	2	ActiveReserve
Parker, Willie RB PIT	MIA	4	0.0	n/a	4	1	97	60	243	1080	4.4	6	20	1	144	694	4.8	2	10	0	ActiveReserve
Active Receiver	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Active Receiver	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Branch, Deion WR NE	BUF	6	0.0	n/a	11		97	64	63	1011	16.0	0	6	0	57	752	13.3	48	4	0	ActiveReserve
Galloway, Joey WR TB	BAL	4	0.0	n/a	4	1	99	92	70	1134	16.2	0	8	0	50	792	15.8	60	6	0	ActiveReserve
Harrison, Marvin WR IND	@NYG	6	0.0	n/a	59		95	48	91	1225	13.5	0	12	0	87	1177	13.5	73	12	1	ActiveReserve
Active Tight End	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Active Tight End	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Shockey, Jeremy TE NYG	IND	4	0.0	n/a	13		96	80	68	876	12.9	0	6	1	58	697	12.0	48	5	0	ActiveReserve
Active Kicker	FGA	FG	FGLg	XPAtt	XP	XPB	Status
Active Kicker	FGA	FG	FGLg	XPAtt	XP	XPB	Status
Vanderjagt, Mike K DAL	@JAC	3	0.0	n/a	3		95	68	31	27	51	36	36	0	29	27	48	53	52	0	ActiveReserve
Active Defense/DST	Int	SACK	DTD	PA	PaNetA	RuYdA	Status
Active Defense/DST	Int	SACK	DTD	PA	PaNetA	RuYdA	Status
Cowboys, DST DST DAL	@JAC	3	0.0	n/a	4		81	41	18	38	3	421	3692	1969	14	35	2	324	3077	1641	ActiveReserve
Reserve Quarterback	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaInt	PaTD	RuTD	Status
Reserve Quarterback	PaAtt	PaCmp	PaYd	PaInt	PaTD	RuTD	Status
Schaub, Matt QB ATL	@CAR	5	0.0	n/a	1		7	0	67	35	402	2	4	0	67	33	412	2	2	0	ActiveReserve
Reserve Running Back	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReTD	Status
Reserve Running Back	RuAtt	RuYd	RuAvg	RuTD	Recpt	ReTD	Status
McAllister, Deuce RB NO	@CLE	7	0.0	n/a	11		14	1	214	866	4.0	5	22	0	238	1017	4.3	7	40	0	ActiveReserve
White, LenDale RB TEN	NYJ	7	0.0	n/a	4		1	0	189	847	4.5	5	16	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0	ActiveReserve
Reserve Receiver	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Reserve Receiver	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Caldwell, Reche WR NE	BUF	6	0.0	n/a	2		6	0	45	540	12.0	0	3	2	18	247	13.7	39	1	1	ActiveReserve
El, Antwaan Randle WR WAS	MIN	8	0.0	n/a	1		52	10	49	622	12.7	0	4	1	38	508	13.2	45	2	2	ActiveReserve
Jenkins, Michael WR ATL	@CAR	5	0.0	n/a	3		18	2	49	681	13.9	0	4	1	22	314	14.6	52	2	0	ActiveReserve
McCareins, Justin WR NYJ	@TEN	9	0.0	n/a	1		26	5	46	668	14.5	0	3	0	49	765	15.7	54	4	0	ActiveReserve
Reserve Tight End	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Reserve Tight End	Recpt	ReYd	ReAvg	ReLg	ReTD	FL	Status
Graham, Daniel TE NE	BUF	6	0.0	n/a	1		26	3	22	269	12.2	0	3	1	28	336	12.0	44	5	0	ActiveReserve
Reserve Kicker	FGA	FG	FGLg	XPAtt	XP	XPB	Status
Reserve Kicker	FGA	FG	FGLg	XPAtt	XP	XPB	Status
Gramatica, Martin K NE	BUF	6	0.0	n/a	1		0	0	22	17	48	16	15	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	ActiveReserve
Reserve Defense/DST	Int	SACK	DTD	PA	PaNetA	RuYdA	Status
Reserve Defense/DST	Int	SACK	DTD	PA	PaNetA	RuYdA	Status
Browns, DST DST CLE	NO	6	0.0	n/a	1		14	4	18	35	2	406	3155	2433	15	30	2	338	2868	2212	ActiveReserve
TOTALS	Active: 10, Reserve: 10, Active Salary: 174, Total Salary: 200, Active Contract: 3, Total Contract: 3