Arbiter - Mod on Mod I

[+Snaps]

So yeah...I challenge you, if you accept you can make rules.

Guardian Devil

Some hot Mod on Mod action, oh yeah!

Arbiter

GFX Moderator

Awesome, I was thinking about challenging you, but you beat me to it.

Topic: Favourite Band/ Favourite Artist (over used but good topic)
Size: 500x500 max
1 PSD max
Due: 1 week

[+Snaps]

Arctic Monkeys -

Arbiter

GFX Moderator

Coldplay pwns


And incase anyone say anything, the four guys are all one render.

[+Snaps]

Let the voting begin...

PuBlIc EnEMY

I vote for Arbiter here...its just a better overall sig...

Arbiter could have worked on his text more though....

I didnt like your's Snapshot because it didnt have any color...also....there was ALOT of negative space....for those of you unfamiliar with this concept, (and I don't mean to sound condescending if I do ) Negative space is simply the area around your main image or figure. Negative space is really vital to creating a harmonious piece. Too much negative space actually pulls dynamism away from your piece, while just the right amount give your piece a feeling of balance of intentionality.
SO here, in the signature we have an overabundance of negative space. How do we solve this? The easiest way would be to reduce the size of the signature. Make the height half as tall. You're next step would be to place the render in a more exciting fashion. One mistake a lot of people make is trying to make you see as much of the render as possible. You never have to do that. Make that render as big as it will go and only show the expressive parts : eyes, mouth, facial expression...one thing that relfects an emotion. The rest of the render will be suggested.

If you do these things, your signature will have more of an impact and be more dynamic.




So my vote goes to Arbiter..

Luke-E

ES- Arctic Monkeys
-Background is ok, does make him look a bit stoned but i like it. 7/10
-Text i like the text, i makes you take notice of the banner. 8/10
-Faults- the size of 'dont belive the hype' it's there first album, i would have had it across the top
-Creativity- good. 7/10
-Overall look. good 8/10

arbiter -coldplay
-Background is good. makes the band stand out.8/10
-Text i dont like the text(maybe it couse i dont like the band) it just looks a bit squashed in. 5/10
-Faults- the size of coldplay it's there name and does not look like the name means any think,
-Creativity- good. 7.5/10
-Overall look. good. 7.5/10

arbiter has doen nearly all my banner and they have all been great but snaps has pulled it all out on this Arctic Monkeys sig, so sorry arbiter hope you will still make my banners.
my vote goes to: snap

http://www.sportzworld.net/

Twist of Lemon

MMA Moderator

lol Im gonna have to go with Arby in this one, Both are good but lacking something. Arby's just seems to like a more complete banner to me.

so Arbiter it is

Omega

Im going to go with Arbiter on this one to, their both ok but if i had to choose i would choose Arbiter only because it has one of the best backgrounds ive ever seen, Emperor's is good but it could use a bit more blending.

VOTE - Arbiter