Which Era/Gimmick Was Better?

Sir Nicky Talent · 09-18-2009, 10:37 AM

In this thread, pick a professional wrestler. Choose two options that span that wrestler's career. List the option below, and the person who posts next must choose which one they enjoyed or liked better and give an elaborate explanation as to why they enjoyed that gimmick or era of that superstar more.

The person who answered then has the opportunity to post the next one.

REMEMBER TO GIVE AN ELABORATE ANSWER. IT'S YOUR OPINION, AS WELL. Just don't let Jim bash you for it.

Here is an example

Quote:

Ric Flair with the Four Horsemen or Ric Flair with Evolution?

You could either post....

Quote:

I have to say The Four Horsemen. It is possibly the greatest stable of all time thanks to Ric Flair. He was booked very well during that time and he had a great companionship with Arn Anderson during his time as world champion with The stable.

or

Quote:

Ric Flair with the Evolution. He was a colorful and wise personality that rounded out the stable and he played the mentor card very well. Though people can argue that the stable's short lenght isn't as effective as Falir's Horsemen run, he still managed to play a great character and win some titles.

Is it easy for you? Let's do the first one:

AJ Styles in TNA or AJ Styles in ROH?

Goldberg · 09-19-2009, 04:28 PM

shouldnt this go in the games section? enyway aj in tna he has been far more succesful and won alot of titles

Diesel Or Kevin Nash?

Marketh. · 09-19-2009, 04:32 PM

If he wants elaboration and a lot of thought as opposed to "he won a lot of titles", then no. Since this isn't intended to be a spam-like game.

I'm not really qualified to comment on Nash, so go ahead whoever wants to.

horrorfan_1986 · 09-19-2009, 05:29 PM

Diesel.

If you want entertainment value, than Kevin Nash is your man. However, Nash was driven and seemed to really try hard when he was Diesel. Off of the top of my head, I can't think of anything he did in WCW that was better than the Survivor Series 1995 or the In Your House: Good Friends, Better Enemy matches. Nash gets some harsh treatment for how 1995 went down. While I think keeping the belt on him for a year wasn't the smartest choice, he tried to do his best with the reign. However, what can you expect when he's booked against Sid and Mabel? Luckily, Bret and Michaels were there to give him a few good title defenses. Nash in WCW is someone who I mainly just think about segments and interview time. The first match that comes to mind is the finger poke of doom. That's not exactly a ringing endorsement for a man's career in a company. Nash may of been a bigger star in WCW, but I'll take his Diesel run over the nWo anytime.

The Steiner Brothers - Tag team babyfaces or heel single stars?

Which Era/Gimmick Was Better?

This is a discussion on Which Era/Gimmick Was Better? within the General Pro Wrestling : Classic & General forums, part of the Wrestling Forums category; In this thread, pick a professional wrestler. Choose two options that span that wrestler's career. List the option below, and ...