This is for Raw & Smackdown, rather than doing one for each.
My Ratings:
Match Making: 7/10. The ECW MITB Match wasnt good match making. I doubt anyone wants to see any of these guys in the match.
Match Writing: 7/10. Getting better.
Promos: 6/10. Need a little more during the actual promos but they have improved a lot.
Spelling/Grammer: 5/10. This seems to be your downfall now. The good news with that is it shows your shows are getting better.
Flow: 7/10. Some just seem to jump from one thing to another with no reason for it.
Overall: 64%. Slowly but surely 