| As for the playoffs thing, Nicky, LeBron also shined in the playoffs, but unfortunately his teammates were SO bad, even he couldn't carry them any further.
As for Brady/Manning, it's tough, it really is.
I mean, they're both really really really good. Manning is absolutely incredible at reading defenses pre-snap, and making adjustments. Or, acting like he's making adjustments when he really doesn't do anything at all. He also has a strong and accurate arm.
However, I'm gonna go with Brady on this one. He's nearly as "cerebral" as Manning, but he's led his team to 3 Super Bowl championships, whereas Manning has not even made the Super Bowl.
I'm not one of those people who says "winning the Super Bowl is everything", because its not. If thats the case, then Trent Dilfer would be a better QB than Manning, Marino, Kelly, etc. But with two guys who are as close as Brady and Manning in my eyes, its a good enough tiebreaker.
Next: Terrell Owens or Randy Moss |