View Single Post
Old 08-10-2007, 12:18 AM   #4 (permalink)
Dr. Giganto
Formerly "Tom Dogg"
Dr. Giganto's Avatar
 
Status: Online
Join Date: Feb 2003
My Local Time: 05:35 PM
Location: New York City
Posts: 10,682
vBookie Cash: 500
Casino Cash: $326
Rep Power: 32 Dr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World ChampionDr. Giganto is World Champion

Points: 31,569, Level: 77
Points: 31,569, Level: 77 Points: 31,569, Level: 77 Points: 31,569, Level: 77
Activity: 39%
Activity: 39% Activity: 39% Activity: 39%

Re: MLB - HOF if they retired today

When I say "yes", that means they'd get in if they retire today. Otherwise, I give an explanation

Barry Bonds - Yes


Ken Griffey Jr. - Yes

Alex Rodriguez - Yes

Roger Clemens - Yes

Pedro Martinez - Yes

Manny Ramirez - Not just yet, but almost there. He'll finish with the numbers necessary to get it

Tom Glavine - Yes

Jason Giambi - Not a chance

Craig Biggio - Borderline...I think he'll get in

Frank Thomas - Borderline, i think he'll get in

Sammy Sosa - Yes

Jorge Posada - Borderline, i think he'll fall short, unless he continues to play at this level for a few more years

Mike Piazza - Yes

Ivan Rodriguez - Yes

Miguel Tejada - No

Gary Sheffield - Maybe...needs a few more good years

Chipper Jones - Maybe...I think he'll fall just short

Vladdy Guerrero - Not yet...needs a few more years

Albert Pujols - If he keeps up this pace, no doubt about it

I'll add a few:

Mariano Rivera - Yes

Trevor Hoffman - Yes

Billy Wagner - Just short

Randy Johnson - Yes

Greg Maddux - Yes

David Ortiz - Not yet...depends on what he does the next few years

Johan Santana - Like Pujols, he's well on his way

John Smoltz - Yes

Andruw Jones - Maybe, but I'm leaning towards no

Ichiro - Depends on what he does, but he'll probably get in

Jeff Kent - Close, but I think he'll be hurt by his bad reputation.

Mike Mussina - No

Jim Thome - Yes

Omar Vizquel - Close, but I think he'll slip through the cracks and not get in

Kenny Rogers - No

Jason Varitek - No

Kenny Lofton - I think he'll get some consideration, but won't quite get there

Derek Jeter - Almost there, will definitely get in

  Reply With Quote