| So...you're saying Vick is as good a QB as Manning? While I see your analogy, my comment was aimed at your suggestion that all Vick does is win. He doesn't. Manning at least gets his team deep into the playoffs and is a constant threat at the QB position. Vick is an occasional threat to break off a long run, but he's seldom the threat Manning is. Or Brady. Or McNabb. Or Favre. Or...you get the picture I think.
If you had one game to win, are you going to go with Manning or Vick? |