| I admittedly dont know that much about the NL, so I'll just comment on the AL
I think the one poor choice I really see is Shea Hillenbrand. He's having a good year, but not a phenomenal year. Plus, Toronto had their representative in Roy Halladay. Also, Danys Baez should not have been the D-Rays representative, it should have been Carl Crawford.
Also, I would have left Paul Konerko off. He's got decent power numbers, but he's only batting .243. I realize the White Sox are the best team in baseball, but its not because of Konerko. If anybody in the White Sox line-up deserved to go, its Scott Podsednik.
So, in short, I would've removed Baez, Konerko, and Hillenbrand, and replaced them with Crawford, and some combination of Jeter, Matsui, and Podsednik |