pp2

Carrying this over from the other thread.

Ok Blitz, I guess the point D and I are trying to make is that the game changes. I think its fair to consider the 80s a different era of baseball as it was before the juiced balls and players of the 90s and current decade. Anyway, as the game changes so does the benchmark for what is considered to be solid statistics. Plus statistics alone don't make for a great player.

I'm going to list some career stats for unnamed players and I would like others to tell me whether or not they think they are HoF material. I'll fill in who they belong to later.

Mystery Player #1
19 years in MLB
Avg: .285
HR: 358
RBI: 1430
SB: 30
Fld % .988

Mystery Player #2
19 years in MLB
Avg: .262
HR: 28
RBI: 793
SB: 580
Fld %: .978

Mystery Player #3
10 years in MLB
Avg: .311
HR: 137
RBI: 734
SB: 197
Fld %: .983

Mystery Player #4
21 years in MLB
AVG: .305
HR: 317
RBI: 1595
SB: 201
Fld %: .970