| * denotes voted in by fans. 1997-2001 stats are for the full season, 2002 and 2004 stats are through All-Star break:
1997: David Cone - 12-6 2.82
Tino Martinez* - .296 44 141
Paul O'Neill* - .324 21 117
Mariano Rivera - 6-4 43 saves 1.88
Bernie Williams - .328 21 100
1999: David Cone - 12-9 3.44
Derek Jeter*- .349 24 102
Mariano Rivera - 4-3 45 saves 1.83
Bernie Williams* - .342 25 115
2000: Derek Jeter* - .339 15 73
Jorge Posada - .287 28 86
Mariano Rivera - 7-4 41 saves 2.85
Bernie Williams* - .307 30 121
2001: Roger Clemens - 20-3 3.51
Derek Jeter .311 21 74
Andy Pettitte - 15-10 3.99
Jorge Posada .277 22 95
Mariano Rivera - 50 saves 2.34
Mike Stanton 9-4 2.58
Bernie Williams .307 26 94
2002: Mariano Rivera 21 saves 1.47 ERA
Robin Ventura - .263 19 62
Jason Giambi* - .318 22 71
Jorge Posada* - .266 15 58
Alfonso Soriano* - .315, 20, 51
Derek Jeter - .312 12 43
2004: Derek Jeter* - .273 13 40
Alex Rodriguez* - .276 19 50
Jason Giambi* - .239 11 31
Javier Vazquez - 9-5 3.50
Tom Gordon - 2 saves 1.51
Mariano Rivera - 29 saves 0.86
Gary Sheffield - .298 13 53
Hideki Matsui* - .282 16 54
The questionable choices I see are Cone in 1997 and 1999 (although a 2.82 ERA in the AL is phenomenal), Pettitte and Stanton in 2001, and Vazquez and Gordon last year (Vazquez, in fact, was an injury replacement, and wasnt originally named an All-Star). Everything else seems justified |