| Yankees:
Catcher: Jorge Posada vs. Alberto Castillo - Posada
1B: Tino Martinez vs. Nick Johnson - Tino
2B: Tony Womack vs. Alfonso Soriano - Soriano in a landslide
SS: Derek Jeter vs. Miguel Cairo (the only person still in MLB to play SS other than Jeter) - Jeter
3B: Alex Rodriguez vs. Aaron Boone - A-Rod
LF: Hideki Matsui vs. Rondell White - Matsui
CF: Bernie Williams vs. Kenny Lofton - This is hard, because they both suck now, but I'll go with Bernie
RF: Gary Sheffield vs. Raul Mondesi - Sheff
DH: Jason Giambi vs. Karim Garcia - Giambi
SP: Randy Johnson vs. Roger Clemens - Clemens
SP: Carl Pavano vs. Andy Pettitte - Pettitte
SP: Mike Mussina vs. David Wells - Mussina
SP: Jaret Wright vs. Jon Lieber - Lieber
SP: Kevin Brown vs. anybody else - anybody else (I'll go with Ted Lilly)
Closer: Mariano Rivera vs. Jeff Nelson (closed a few games when Rivera was hurt) - Rivera |